Review call

Apply for a review call.

Send your website and a little about the firm. We review it before we speak, then we talk for 30 minutes on video. Afterwards you get examples of what we'd change and a short proposal.

What would you most like to improve?

We reply within one working day. Your details are only used to reply to you (privacy).

← All guides

Websites

Redesigning your website without losing your Google rankings

For businesses about to replace an existing website. You'll get the reasons redesigns lose traffic, a step-by-step checklist for before, during and after launch, and what's normal in the weeks that follow.

By Devon MacMillan, Orderhatch · updated 15 October 2026 · 4 min read
Hands sketching website layouts on paper with sticky notes around them
Photo: @uxindo on Unsplash

Why redesigns lose rankings

A new design on its own rarely hurts your search traffic. What hurts is what changes alongside it. The usual causes are:

  • Page addresses change and the old ones aren't redirected, so links and search results lead to error pages.
  • Pages that brought in visitors are removed or merged without anyone checking.
  • Useful text is cut back for a cleaner look, so Google has less to understand the page by.
  • Page titles and headings are rewritten without keeping the words people search for.
  • A setting that hid the test site from Google is left switched on after launch.
  • The new site is slower, especially on phones.

All of these are avoidable with some preparation. Google's own guide to moving a site with URL changes sets out the same approach this checklist follows.

Before you start: take an inventory

0 of 5 ticked

Build a redirect map

A redirect map is a simple list of every old address and where it should go on the new site. Google recommends server-side permanent redirects (301 or 308), pointing straight to the final page, and says permanent redirects don't cause a loss of ranking signals.

Old addressNew addressNote
/services/boiler-repair.html/boiler-repairSame page, new address
/about-us/aboutSame page, new address
/news/winter-opening-2023/newsOld news item, closest relevant page
/menu-lunch and /menu-dinner/menuTwo pages merged into one

Avoid sending lots of old pages to the homepage. Google may treat that as a missing page rather than a redirect. Send each one to the closest equivalent instead.

Keep what already works

A redesign is a good moment to tidy up, but be careful about cutting the text on pages that already bring in visitors. Google can only rank a page for what it says. If your boiler repair page currently explains areas covered, typical jobs and what to expect, keep that substance even if the layout changes.

  • Keep the main words people search for in the page title and main heading of each important page.
  • Carry over useful text, then improve it, rather than starting from a blank page.
  • Keep frequently asked questions, opening hours and prices as real text, not inside images.
  • Keep the internal links between related pages so visitors and Google can still find their way around.

A redesign is also a chance to make the site easier for everyone to use. Checking the new design against the WCAG 2.2 accessibility guidelines costs little at this stage and helps every visitor.

Launch day checklist

  • Remove any 'noindex' setting or password protection used on the test site.
  • Switch on the redirects and test a sample of old URLs, including your top ten pages.
  • Check every page has a sensible title and one main heading.
  • Submit the new sitemap in Search Console.
  • If the domain itself has changed, use Search Console's Change of Address tool. It isn't needed if only the paths changed.
  • Update internal links so they point at new addresses directly rather than through redirects.
  • Test forms, bookings, payments and phone links on a real phone.
  • Check speed against Google's Core Web Vitals.
  • Update the website link on your Google Business Profile and social accounts if anything changed.

After launch: what's normal and what to watch

Google says to expect temporary fluctuation in rankings during a move, and that for medium-sized sites it can take a few weeks or more for new addresses to replace the old ones in results. A short dip is normal. A steep, lasting drop is a sign that something on the checklist was missed.

0 of 4 ticked

At Orderhatch, when we redesign a site we stay close to what already works, build the redirect map first, and keep watching Search Console after launch.

Quick answers

Will a redesign hurt my rankings?

It doesn't have to. With redirects, the same useful content and a careful launch, most sites hold their position after a short settling period.

How long should I keep redirects?

As long as possible. Google recommends at least a year, and there's little reason to remove them.

Can I change my domain name at the same time?

You can, but it adds risk. If you can, change one big thing at a time.

What's the most common mistake?

Forgetting to redirect old page addresses, closely followed by leaving the test site's 'hide from Google' setting switched on.

Want this done for your business?

A fixed price within one working day, from the person who'll build it.

Talk to us about a redesign

Sources

Keep reading